The wise Ginny Redish once said, “Too many usability tests focus only on finding information—not on how the information itself works for people.” Amen. But, why is testing whether content works for people a good idea? Why is it worth spending time and money? Let’s look at five reasons why.

5 – Show Progress Quickly

With content, many results take time to achieve. Domain authority doesn’t happen overnight. Attracting more qualified sales leads doesn’t happen in an instant. Changing perceptions of your brand takes longer than a blink of the eye. In the meantime, you need to involve your team or your client in progress. Why? To build and sustain your momentum. The Progress Principle explains a multi-year research study of work and momentum. Researchers Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer note that


Testing your content will show meaningful progress—and help people feel that progress—before you get those long term results. For example, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) tested their current approach to Traveler’s Health content against a new concept. The concept tested far better with users. That testing helped CDC’s Kelly Holton rally support for “reimagining” the approach to content. And, of course, that saves costs on delays, extra communication, lack of productivity, and similar quagmires of large projects.

4 – Do Projects And Make Content Decisions Faster In The Future

When you test content, you gain valuable insights about your users or customers, your products or services, your brand, and, of course, the content. If you keep those insights, you can apply them to other projects and other content decisions. You don’t have to test the same thing over and over again. One of my clients kept their testing insights in “The Big Book of Knowledge.” Whenever a new project or big decision came up, the client could check the book for insights from similar projects or decisions in the past.

3 – Solve Problems Efficiently

It’s tough to solve problems if you don’t know why they’re happening. When you detect a problem with your website, mobile site, or another part of your online presence, testing content can help you diagnose the problem. And, then, you can figure out how to solve it. For example, University of Georgia’s Terry College of Business tested their MBA content to understand why it wasn’t as compelling as it could be. One of their discoveries was that the difference between their three MBA programs was unclear to prospective students. That finding led Terry to clarify the differences between the programs. If UGA gains even one more student thanks to the clarified content, that will more than pay for the testing.

2 – Gain New Insights For Little Cost

In response to testing content, I’ve never, ever heard anyone say, “Gee, I really learned nothing new here.” For example, at Cingular Wireless many years ago, my team’s testing of My Account (the account management area of led to simple but effective content improvements. That testing cost, what, maybe $50,000? And the return on those improvements across 50 million customers was mind boggling.

1 – Reduce Risk Of Expensive Failures + Problems

You would not put out a product, service, or idea without testing it, right? It would be irresponsible to your customers and very risky to your business or organization.  We share space with the leading health footwear retailer FootSmart. We see prototypes of new FootSmart-brand comfort shoes all the time. FootSmart tests those shoes at every step (forgive the pun) of their creation. Why? Because the risk of putting out an unsatisfactory product is too great.

In the same way, putting out a new approach to content on a large scale without testing it is irresponsible and risky. CDC has tested each redesign of As another example, The New York Times has created a permanent beta area called Test Drive, where users test the media giant’s new ideas before the media giant unleashes those ideas on everyone else.

Am I saying test every bit of content? No. While you can’t test all content, you can test big ideas, major decisions, and huge changes in direction. For example, we advised a health media startup on a methodology for developing and testing tone. Tone is a big decision that affects all content. If you get tone wrong, you risk being unappealing to the audience and undifferentiated from competition. Is that a risk worth taking?

The Bottom Line

When you form a content and user experience strategy, you make big decisions about content tone, message, topics, architecture, and more that you and your users have to live with for a long time. Really, the question is can you afford not to test those decisions?

Of course, testing content is only the tip of the iceberg for evaluating whether your content works for people and, if not, how to adjust it. With survey mechanisms, multichannel analytics, search analytics, customer data, and more at our disposal, we have the power to understand when our content works and when it doesn’t. But, we can’t use that power if we don’t take time to assess, interpret, and form insights.

To help you plan for the power of content testing and evaluation, here are a few resources from me and other people who think about the topic.

Originally published on the now-archived Content Science blog in July 2012.

The Author

Colleen Jones is the founder and CEO of Content Science, a growing content intelligence and strategy company based in Atlanta GA. Content Science owns Content Science Review, Content Science Academy, and the content effectiveness software ContentWRX.  Colleen regularly consults with executives and practitioners to improve their strategy and processes for content. She shares insights and guidance from her experience regularly on Content Science Review, at events around the world, and in highly rated books such as Clout: The Art and Science of Influential Web Content.

Follow Colleen on Twitter at @leenjones or on LinkedIn.

This article is about
Related Topics:



We invite you to share your perspective in a constructive way. To comment, please sign in or register. Our moderating team will review all comments and may edit them for clarity. Our team also may delete comments that are off-topic or disrespectful. All postings become the property of
Content Science Review.

Partner Whitepapers

The 3 Elements of Content Intelligence

Make better content decisions with a system of data + insight.

Digital Transformation for Marketing

Your content approach makes or breaks your digital transformation. Learn why intelligent content strategy + engineering are critical to your success.

Content Strategy for Products + Services

Your content is integral to your product. You might have piloted content strategy and seen promising results. Now what? It’s time to get more strategic so you can sustain and scale. This whitepaper will help you start.

Help with Content Analytics + ROI

Does your content work? It's a simple question, but getting a clear answer from content analytics or ROI formulas is often anything but easy. This ebook by Colleen Jones will help you overcome the challenges.